 |
Complete digital issues and interactive resources for subscribers to The New York Times Upfront—perfect for your interactive whiteboard, projector, or computer. |
Subscribers
Click here for your magazine's digital resources.
Click here for your magazine's digital resources.
Not a Subscriber?
Password protection is coming soon! To ensure continued access, subscribe now.
Teachers, Talk to Us!
Need help?
Free Teacher e-Newsletter
Get teaching tips, information, and resources that connect to the magazine! Enter your e-mail address:
©Jeff Parker/Florida Today & the Fort Myers News-Press/Cagle Cartoons
June 17, 2013
Criminal Suspects and DNA
- The Supreme Court recently ruled that police may take DNA samples of suspects they’re arresting in connection with serious crimes. Why do you think the suspect here is depicted as the Statue of Liberty, and how does the symbolism help you understand the cartoonist’s point of view?
- Supporters of DNA collection say having a DNA database of suspects can help law enforcement solve old and future crimes; opponents argue that the practice violates the Fourth Amendment protection against “unreasonable searches.” Which side of the debate do you agree with and why?
- Do you think collecting DNA swabs of suspects is different from getting their fingerprints or mug shots? Why or why not?
- Should Americans be willing to give up some liberties to ensure better security or to help with law enforcement? Are there rights that you think should never be compromised?
