You just got your writing assignment back from your teacher. At the top is a C+. Does that grade reflect what you learned by writing the paper? That’s one of the questions at the heart of the debate over letter grades, which teachers have traditionally used to report student performance.
Some educators question whether letter grades are useful. A letter can’t convey what a student needs to do to improve, critics say, and a low grade can be discouraging for a student. But supporters of letter grades say their simplicity is exactly what makes them useful: Everyone knows the difference between an A and an F.
So should schools stop giving letter grades? A learning assessment expert and an education researcher square off.