Ethical Dilemma

Ryan McVay/Getty Images (Delivery Man); Aaron Amat/Shutterstock.com (Boy)

Post Office Refund?

A package I recently sent was guaranteed to be delivered the next day by noon but instead arrived at 12:03. Though I’m fully satisfied with the overnight delivery, I’m technically entitled to a full refund. Is it ethical to ask for my money back?  —Ross Nizlek, Burlington, Vermont

You shouldn’t ask for a refund. Technically, the service did “fail.” But there are many reasons someone might be 3 (or even 23) minutes late, and it’s wrong to ignore those factors simply because the language of the rules is inflexible. Whenever people or organizations try to fulfill their professional duties with a reasonable degree of diligence, allow some room for minor human error. If the Postal Service didn’t time-stamp deliveries, the idea of complaining wouldn’t have even occurred to you. Demanding a refund when you’re “fully satisfied” is a form of theft.

—Adapted from “The Ethicist” in The New York Times Magazine

Tell us what you think.
NOTE: Please include ONLY your first name. Comments that include last names or inappropriate language will not be posted. Comments are moderated by Scholastic editors.
Thanks for your comment! It’ll post as soon as it’s approved. Check back soon!
This field is required Please enter a valid Name (name cannot contain space, %, <,>,^,\)
Comment
It’s very quiet here, start the conversation by adding your comment above.
Text-to-Speech