Standards

Should Schools Stop Giving Letter Grades?

David Tanecek/CTK Photo/Alamy Live News

You just got your writing assignment back from your teacher. At the top is a C+. Does that grade reflect what you learned by writing the paper? That’s one of the questions at the heart of the debate over letter grades, which teachers have traditionally used to report student performance.

Some educators question whether letter grades are useful. A letter can’t convey what a student needs to do to improve, critics say, and a low grade can be discouraging for a student. But supporters of letter grades say their simplicity is exactly what makes them useful: Everyone knows the difference between an A and an F.

So should schools stop giving letter grades? A learning assessment expert and an education researcher square off.

Traditional grading—A, B, C, D, F—is often unfair to students. We should replace it with grading methods that are better at representing what students have actually learned.

A letter grade is typically based on a 0 to 100 scale, with work scoring below 60 getting an F. That means more than half of the possible points a student can achieve on an assignment—0 to 59—could earn an F. Also, a single zero for late work could significantly lower a course average and be difficult to recover from.

Furthermore, a letter grade can be a poor measure of what a student has learned in a course, especially if it’s based in part on factors other than coursework. Some teachers change a letter grade based on a student’s participation or behavior. Does a B mean you didn’t learn as much as others just because you didn’t raise your hand as often? And letter grades often don’t capture a student’s growth: Even if you’ve demonstrated A-level learning by the end of the semester, any low marks you got in the beginning can result in a lower final grade, which makes the grade’s meaning unclear.

It’s often unclear what a letter grade actually measures.

Seeking alternatives to traditional letter grades, some schools are experimenting with “standards-based grading,” in which students are scored on individual skills using a 1 to 4 proficiency scale rather than receiving a single A-to-F grade. A more radical approach is “ungrading,” where students get feedback on their work to help them improve but no grades during the semester. At the end, they do a final self-assessment and work with their teacher to arrive at a grade that best reflects what they’ve learned. That places responsibility on students to do the work to support their learning, not just because it counts for a grade.

Changing traditional grading practices is difficult. But just because it has always been done one way doesn’t mean it’s fair or accurate. Shouldn’t grades reflect exactly what you’ve learned?


—E. CAROLINE WYLIE
Senior Associate, National Center for the Improvement of Educational Assessment

Letter grades are an effective means of representing academic progress and motivating students. A letter grade can incorporate various aspects of student performance, from coursework to behavior, which makes it a true measure of learning.

As a teacher and administrator, I’ve seen how motivating letter grades can be. Students who don’t put in their best effort on early assignments receive an F and subsequently adopt better habits to rescue their course average. They take ownership over their learning.

A low letter grade also conveys high expectations. It’s perfectly justified for a teacher to give an F to a student who completed 50 percent of the work or put in a half-hearted effort. Performing at 50 percent would be unheard of outside of class, in sports or at work. It should be unacceptable in coursework too.

Some say letter grades shouldn’t incorporate nonacademic factors such as participation or the timely submission of work. But I think they should. Participation and punctuality are part of the learning process. To create well-rounded adults, we must incentivize good habits. Grades can be a reflection of consistency, reliability, and tenacity—basic requirements in life.

A letter grade sums up student performance in a simple data point.

It’s precisely because letter grades can condense a number of academic and behavioral factors into a simple data point that their meaning is clear—as clear as the 100-point scale on which they’re based. Parents and college enrollment officers can immediately understand what a letter grade means.

I’m not opposed to new approaches to grading, as all of them try to reward academic progress and can serve as motivation for students. But while much has been written about why such reforms ought to work, there’s little evidence they actually do. Until more evidence arises, the standard A-to-F scale, whatever its faults, is still the best we’ve got.


—DANIEL BUCK
Former teacher, Research Fellow, American Enterprise Institute

By the Numbers

77%

PERCENTAGE of teachers who say their district uses letter grades, numerical grades, or a combination of the two.

2 in 3

NUMBER of teachers who say the benefit of letter grades is that parents understand them. Twenty-three percent cited student motivation.

Source: Edweek Research Center

What does your class think?

Should schools stop giving letter grades?

Please enter a valid number of votes for one class to proceed.

Should schools stop giving letter grades?

Please select an answer to vote.

Should schools stop giving letter grades?

0%
0votes
{{result.answer}}
Total Votes: 0
Thank you for voting!
Sorry, an error occurred and your vote could not be processed. Please try again later.
Skills Sheets (1)
Lesson Plan (1)
Text-to-Speech