Standards

Standing Your Ground

States are pushing to pass laws allowing more reasons to use deadly force in self-defense.

Superstock/Everett Collection

Images from Hollywood have cemented the idea of protecting your property by any means necessary.

When does an ordinary American have the right to use deadly force? Tennessee legislators recently answered that question with a law that makes it easier to legally shoot someone who’s stealing your property. The law expands on the so-called “stand your ground” legal doctrine, which previously allowed you to defend yourself—but not your possessions—from attack. Under Tennessee’s new provision, it’s now legal in that state to kill to protect your belongings as long as you believe the would-be thief is a threat to yourself or others.

When does an ordinary American have the right to use deadly force? Tennessee legislators recently answered that question. A new law in that state makes it easier to legally shoot someone who’s stealing your property. The law expands on the so-called “stand your ground” legal doctrine. The law previously allowed you to defend yourself—but not your possessions—from attack. Under Tennessee’s new provision, it’s now legal in that state to kill to protect your belongings as long as you believe the would-be thief is a threat to yourself or others.

38 states now have stand-your-ground protections.

Since Florida passed the first comprehensive stand-your-ground law in 2005, the right to defend yourself with lethal force has steadily grown in the United States. Thirty-eight states now have stand-your-ground protections.

In those states, “there is no duty to retreat when you’re in public spaces,” says Kami Chavis, a criminal justice professor at the William & Mary Law School. This is a big shift away from traditional self-defense law, which says you can’t use force “if you have the opportunity to get to safety or seek help,” Chavis notes.

Since Florida passed the first comprehensive stand-your-ground law in 2005, the right to defend yourself with lethal force has steadily grown in the United States. Thirty-eight states now have stand-your-ground protections.

In those states, “there is no duty to retreat when you’re in public spaces,” says Kami Chavis, a criminal justice professor at the William & Mary Law School. This is a big shift away from traditional self-defense law, which says you can’t use force “if you have the opportunity to get to safety or seek help,” Chavis notes.

THE SECOND AMENDMENT

“A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.”

For hundreds of years, the Second Amendment’s language was viewed as ambiguous.

For hundreds of years, the Second Amendment’s language was viewed as ambiguous.

The Duty to Retreat

For roughly the first century of U.S. history, the nation followed English common law,* which said you had a duty to retreat in the face of someone’s aggression before resorting to deadly force. The one exception, known as the “castle doctrine,” applied only inside one’s home.

The castle doctrine “allowed people to use lethal violence in self-defense as long as they were . . . defending their homes, or ‘castles,’” says Caroline Light, a historian at Harvard University.

But that began to change in the late 1800s, as Americans started legally challenging the duty to retreat. In 1921, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the murder conviction of a man who had killed someone who had threatened him with a knife (see “Second Amendment Cases,” below). In the landmark decision Brown v. U.S., the Court ruled that a person doesn’t have a duty to retreat and can stand their ground if they reasonably fear for their life.

At the same time, the proliferation of guns that had begun in the 19th century was changing the dynamics of self-defense and how the courts ruled on it. Surplus guns flooded the country after the Civil War, and industrialization made mass production of firearms easier.

Manufacturers evoked the wild Western frontier to sell guns. However, the image of gunfighting cowboys dueling on a dusty Main Street—later popularized on TV and in films—was largely a myth, historians say. Many frontier towns, such as Dodge City, Kansas, and Deadwood, South Dakota, had laws that banned people from carrying firearms in town. Still, that image of the brave American defending his honor with a gun took hold in the culture.

For roughly the first century of U.S. history, the nation followed English common law.* It said you had a duty to retreat in the face of someone’s aggression before resorting to deadly force. The one exception was known as the “castle doctrine.” It applied only to inside one’s home.

The castle doctrine “allowed people to use lethal violence in self-defense as long as they were . . . defending their homes, or ‘castles,’” says Caroline Light, a historian at Harvard University.

But that began to change in the late 1800s. Americans started legally challenging the requirement to retreat. In 1921, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the murder conviction of a man who had killed someone who had threatened him with a knife (see “Second Amendment Cases,” below). In the landmark decision Brown v. U.S., the Court ruled that a person doesn’t have a duty to retreat and can stand their ground if they reasonably fear for their life.

At the same time, the proliferation of guns that had begun in the 19th century was changing the dynamics of self-defense and how the courts ruled on it. Surplus guns flooded the country after the Civil War. Industrialization made mass production of firearms easier.

Manufacturers evoked the wild Western frontier to sell guns. However, historians say the popular image of gunfighting cowboys dueling on a dusty Main Street was largely untrue. Many frontier towns, such as Dodge City, Kansas, and Deadwood, South Dakota, had laws that banned people from carrying firearms in town. Still, that image of the brave American defending his honor with a gun became part of the culture.

The Second Amendment
The text has been interpreted many different ways over the decades in an effort to balance the right to bear arms with gun control.

A Personal Right?

As guns became increasingly common, the courts came to see them as a legally protected element of self-defense. That culminated in the 2008 case District of Columbia v. Heller, in which the Supreme Court ruled that the Second Amendment ensures the right of citizens to own guns for protection.

The language of the Second Amendment, as written by the framers of the Constitution, had long been viewed as ambiguous about whether it protected the right of individuals “to keep and bear arms” or the right of the states to keep “a well-regulated militia.” In the Heller decision, the Court affirmed the individual interpretation.

“The Court said the core of this right is self-defense, and that was a big change,” says Joseph Blocher, a professor at the Duke University School of Law. “Heller was the birth of the modern Second Amendment.”

This new interpretation has opened up more opportunities for legal challenges to gun laws as violating an individual’s constitutional right to a firearm for self-defense, experts say.

As guns became increasingly common, the courts came to see them as a legally protected element of self-defense. In the 2008 case District of Columbia v. Heller, the Supreme Court ruled that the Second Amendment ensures the right of citizens to own guns for protection.

The language of the Second Amendment, as written by the framers of the Constitution, had long been viewed as ambiguous. Did it protect the right of individuals “to keep and bear arms” or the right of the states to keep “a well-regulated militia”? In the Heller decision, the Court affirmed the individual interpretation.

“The Court said the core of this right is self-defense, and that was a big change,” says Joseph Blocher, a professor at the Duke University School of Law. “Heller was the birth of the modern Second Amendment.”

This new interpretation has opened up more opportunities for legal challenges to gun laws. The laws can be interpreted as violating an individual’s constitutional right to a firearm for self-defense, experts say.

*A legal system that originated in medieval England

*A legal system that originated in medieval England

Carson Senfield Foundation https://carsonsenfieldfoundation.com

Carson Senfield’s family started a foundation in his memory.

The Safety Debate

In 2021, Ohio and Arkansas became the most recent states to pass stand-your-ground laws. While a majority of U.S. states today have stand-your ground statutes, whether the laws serve to make Americans safer is the subject of debate.

Opponents point to studies linking the laws to rising homicide rates and cases where innocent people have been killed. One of the most well-known cases was the 2012 death of Black 17-year-old Trayvon Martin. He was unarmed and was walking back to his father’s fiancée’s house in Sanford, Florida, after buying snacks at a convenience store. On his way home, Martin was shot by George Zimmerman, who is White and Hispanic and was then a neighborhood watchman.

Zimmerman was found not guilty in court under Florida’s stand-your-ground law. The verdict, and the case’s racial dynamics, sparked protests in cities across the nation.

In 2021, Ohio and Arkansas became the most recent states to pass stand-your-ground laws. The majority of U.S. states today have stand-your-ground statutes. But there is debate whether the laws serve to make Americans safer.

Opponents point to studies linking the laws to rising homicide rates and cases where innocent people have been killed. One of the most well-known cases was the 2012 death of Black 17-year-old Trayvon Martin. He was unarmed and was walking back from a convenience store to his father’s fiancée’s house in Sanford, Florida. On his way home, Martin was shot by George Zimmerman, who is White and Hispanic. At the time, Zimmerman was a neighborhood watchman.

Zimmerman was found not guilty in court under Florida’s stand-your-ground law. The verdict, and the case’s racial dynamics, sparked protests in cities across the nation.

Opponents point to studies linking the laws to rising homicide rates.

Stand-your-ground laws have also been linked to higher rates of gun homicide among adolescents. In recent years, several high-profile stand-your-ground killings have involved young people. In 2022, 19-year-old Carson Senfield was shot and killed in Florida when he tried to get into a car that he thought was his Uber. In 2023, 16-year-old Ralph Yarl of Missouri was shot after ringing the wrong doorbell. He survived but suffered a traumatic brain injury. Yarl’s shooter pleaded guilty to second-degree assault. In Senfield’s case, prosecutors didn’t press charges after determining that the shooter was protected by Florida’s stand-your-ground law.

Supporters of stand-your-ground laws say that individuals have a right to protect themselves in public and shouldn’t have to risk their safety by retreating from an attacker. A majority of Americans agree, with 58 percent supporting the laws, according to a 2023 poll by NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist. That year, an article published in the medical journal Injury Prevention found that nearly 80 percent of the American gun owners surveyed own a firearm for personal protection. That’s up from 48 percent in 2013.

Stand-your-ground laws have also been linked to higher rates of gun homicide among adolescents. In recent years, several high-profile stand-your-ground killings have involved young people. In 2022, 19-year-old Carson Senfield was shot and killed in Florida when he tried to get into a car that he thought was his Uber. In 2023, 16-year-old Ralph Yarl of Missouri was shot after ringing the wrong doorbell. He survived but suffered a traumatic brain injury. Yarl’s shooter pleaded guilty to second-degree assault.

In Senfield’s case, prosecutors didn’t press charges after determining that the shooter was protected by Florida’s stand-your-ground law.

Supporters of stand-your-ground laws say that individuals have a right to protect themselves in public. They shouldn’t have to risk their safety by retreating from an attacker. A majority of Americans agree. According to a 2023 NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll, 58 percent of Americans support the laws. That year, an article published in the medical journal Injury Prevention found that nearly 80 percent of the American gun owners surveyed own a firearm for personal protection. That’s up from 48 percent in 2013.

Right or Obligation?

Robert Alexander/Getty Images

A warning sign posted in the front yard of a New Mexico homeowner

In passing its new stand-your-ground provision, Tennessee joins Texas as the second state to allow the use of deadly force to protect property.

The Tennessee law, which went into effect in July, sparked heated debate among the state’s legislators. Proponents say it allows people to protect themselves from significant financial and personal harm caused by serious crimes, including arson and burglary.

“This critical step supports victims, especially in rural communities where law enforcement response times are understandably longer,” says Kip Capley, the Republican state representative who introduced the legislation.

Critics argue that the law could embolden people to use deadly force in situations that don’t warrant it.

“We’re encouraging escalation,” Democratic state representative Justin Jones told NPR.

Beyond Tennessee, the right to stand your ground continues to grow. Georgia and Missouri have also strengthened their stand-your-ground protections this year. Experts say the expansion of these laws demonstrates how Americans increasingly view safety as an individual responsibility.

“Stand-your-ground laws define self-defense not only as an American right but an American obligation,” says Light, the Harvard historian, “and firearms are seen as the number one tool.”

Tennessee joins Texas as the second state to allow the use of deadly force to protect property.

The Tennessee law went into effect in July. It sparked heated debate among the state’s legislators. Proponents say it allows people to protect themselves from significant financial and personal harm caused by serious crimes, including arson and burglary.

“This critical step supports victims, especially in rural communities where law enforcement response times are understandably longer,” says Kip Capley, the Republican state representative who introduced the legislation.

Critics argue that the law could motivate people to use deadly force in situations that don’t warrant it.

“We’re encouraging escalation,” Democratic state representative Justin Jones told NPR.

Beyond Tennessee, the right to stand your ground continues to grow. Georgia and Missouri have also strengthened their stand-your-ground protections this year. Experts say the expansion of these laws demonstrates how Americans increasingly view safety as an individual responsibility.

“Stand-your-ground laws define self-defense not only as an American right but an American obligation,” says Light, the Harvard historian, “and firearms are seen as the number one tool.”

58%

PERCENTAGE of Americans who support stand-your-ground laws.

Source: NPR/PBS Newshour/Marist poll, 2023

PERCENTAGE of Americans who support stand-your-ground laws.

Source: NPR/PBS Newshour/Marist poll, 2023

Stand-Your-Ground Laws in the U.S.

Jim McMahon (map) | Source: Giffords Law Center

RED: Stand-your-ground laws; BROWN: Court decisions establishing stand-your-ground rights*; GREEN: Duty to retreat (no stand-your-ground laws)

*When courts rule on cases, they sometimes establish legal precedents in the regions they cover.

RED: Stand-your-ground laws; BROWN: Court decisions establishing stand-your-ground rights*; GREEN: Duty to retreat (no stand-your-ground laws)

*When courts rule on cases, they sometimes establish legal precedents in the regions they cover.

Second Amendment Cases

Five Supreme Court gun rulings to know

1895: Beard v. United States

In its first ruling addressing the duty to retreat, the Supreme Court said that it doesn’t apply on someone’s land. The Court overturned the manslaughter conviction of Babe Beard, who shot and killed a trespasser who had threatened him on his Arkansas farm. This ruling expanded the castle doctrine from inside the home to the surrounding property.

In its first ruling addressing the duty to retreat, the Supreme Court said that it doesn’t apply on someone’s land. The Court overturned the manslaughter conviction of Babe Beard, who shot and killed a trespasser who had threatened him on his Arkansas farm. This ruling expanded the castle doctrine from inside the home to the surrounding property.

1921: Brown v. United States

The Court overturned the murder conviction of a Texas construction worker who fatally shot a man threatening him with a knife. The ruling expanded self-defense beyond Beard, establishing that someone can use deadly force to defend themselves anywhere they have a legal right to be.

The Court overturned the murder conviction of a Texas construction worker who fatally shot a man threatening him with a knife. The ruling expanded self-defense beyond Beard, establishing that someone can use deadly force to defend themselves anywhere they have a legal right to be.

2008: District of Columbia v. Heller

A Washington, D.C., police officer sued the city after it denied him a license to have a handgun at home. The Court ruled 5-4 that the Second Amendment safeguarded the right of citizens to own guns for protection.

A Washington, D.C., police officer sued the city after it denied him a license to have a handgun at home. The Court ruled 5-4 that the Second Amendment safeguarded the right of citizens to own guns for protection.

2022: New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen

In a 6-3 decision, the Court said that the Constitution protects the right to carry a concealed gun in public for self-defense. The ruling struck down a New York State law that required people to prove they had a special reason to do so.

In a 6-3 decision, the Court said that the Constitution protects the right to carry a concealed gun in public for self-defense. The ruling struck down a New York State law that required people to prove they had a special reason to do so.

2024: United States v. Rahimi

The Court ruled 8-1 that a law banning gun ownership for people under domestic violence restraining orders didn’t violate the Second Amendment. The Court said there was longstanding legal precedent for disarming people who pose a threat to others.

The Court ruled 8-1 that a law banning gun ownership for people under domestic violence restraining orders didn’t violate the Second Amendment. The Court said there was longstanding legal precedent for disarming people who pose a threat to others.

videos (1)
Skills Sheets (2)
Skills Sheets (2)
Leveled Articles (1)
Text-to-Speech